7 Best Cheapest Workers’ Comp Insurance for Self-Employed in 2026

Mark Paulson
group of person on stairs; workers comp insurance

I’ve spent years helping solo owners and tiny teams sort out insurance, and workers’ comp is always the knotty one. It’s required in many states, priced off payroll and risk class, and full of jargon that makes your eyes glaze over. I first delved deeply into this when a contractor on my small content team got hurt while working a weekend side job. No one knew who paid what, and I promised myself I’d never be that unprepared again.

My goal was simple: find legitimate coverage that satisfied state rules, didn’t crush cash flow, and worked even if payroll was just me. I talked with brokers, tested a few online quotes, and compared how carriers handle low payrolls and seasonal spikes. Here’s the truth I learned: the cheapest option isn’t a “discount policy.” It’s the carrier or marketplace that prices your class code fairly, offers pay-as-you-go billing, and won’t hit you with surprise audits.

The most successful solo contractors and consultants keep it boring and compliant. They use pay-as-you-go, file certificates on time, and pick a carrier that’s responsive during claims. You don’t need a huge name or a white-glove package.

Comparison of 7 best workers’ comp insurance in 2026 with pricing and recommended use cases

Tool / Platform Best For Pricing
Next Insurance Fast online quotes, pay-as-you-go Quote-based; monthly billing available
biBERK (Berkshire Hathaway) Low overhead buyers wanting A++ backing Quote-based; pay-as-you-go/premium options
Pie Insurance Price-sensitive small contractors/trades Quote-based; flexible deposit options
Thimble Freelancers needing easy COIs on demand Quote-based; monthly pay options
The Hartford Pros wanting strong endorsements/support Quote-based; pay-as-you-go via payroll
Cerity (Employers Insurance) Sole props wanting quick bind online Quote-based; instant bind in many states
Simply Business (Marketplace) Comparing multiple carriers in minutes Brokered quotes; carrier pricing varies

What is workers’ comp insurance?

Workers’ compensation insurance is a state-regulated business policy that covers medical bills, wage replacement, and related benefits if you or your employees get hurt while working. Its core purpose is to protect people and keep businesses compliant. There’s a simple rule I live by: protect your downside first. For self-employed folks, that means securing coverage that pays when you can’t. It’s about control over risk and keeping work moving.

Think of it this way: a single emergency room visit can run into thousands of dollars. One lost week of income can equal a month of premiums. Coverage turns a scary, lumpy risk into a steady, known cost. In practice, independent contractors, freelancers, and sole proprietors use workers’ comp to satisfy client requirements, comply with state regulations, and cover on-the-job injuries. Payroll and job class codes feed into rating, which produces a premium and audits at year-end.

Many pair workers’ comp with general liability, professional liability, or a business owner’s policy (BOP). Pay-as-you-go billing through payroll providers can smooth cash flow and avoid large audits. Not all providers are equal on price, billing, or claims support—so it pays to compare carefully.

How to choose the best workers’ comp insurance

Choosing a policy can feel overwhelming. Every state has different rules, and pricing depends on your class code and payroll. It’s a lot to weigh when you just want to stay compliant and keep working. I pulled this guide together to help you find a fit for your exact situation, whether you’re a solo owner, part-time help, or a seasonal crew. I focused on real cash flow, certificate needs, and the headaches that pop up later, like audits.

Most content on this topic is either from carriers selling policies or media with sponsored lists. I am not sponsored by any platform on this list. This is my honest read after research, quotes, and many conversations with providers.

Here are some questions you should ask when looking for a policy:

  • How flexible is billing—can I do true pay-as-you-go with payroll?
  • Is the quote process simple, and can I bind coverage online the same day?
  • Will the policy scale if I add part-time or 1099 help later?
  • What happens to my premium if my payroll doubles—or gets cut in half?
  • Are certificates of insurance (COIs) free and instant for new clients?
  • Can I track endorsements, audit history, and claims easily online?
  • How hard is it to switch carriers after a year if rates change?
  • What safety resources or return-to-work support does the carrier offer?
  • Are there state-specific rules I should know (e.g., owner exclusion, ghost policies)?

7 best workers’ comp insurance in 2026

Here are my top picks for the best workers’ comp insurance:

  1. Next Insurance
  2. biBERK (Berkshire Hathaway)
  3. Pie Insurance
  4. Thimble
  5. The Hartford
  6. Cerity (Employers Insurance)
  7. Simply Business (Marketplace)

Let’s see which one is right for you.

1. Next Insurance

Screenshot of Next Insurance homepage

Next Insurance is a digital-first carrier built for small businesses and solo owners. It’s known for quick online quotes, same-day bind, and clean policy management. The company has raised significant funding and expanded nationally over the last several years, becoming a familiar name for freelancers and trades. You can start with a short form and usually see a quote in minutes. The dashboard is straightforward: get certificates instantly, manage endorsements, and add coverage if a client asks. Daily tasks feel simple—download a COI, update payroll estimates, or add an additional insured.

Recent improvements focus on bundling and faster underwriting in more class codes, which helps if you work in non-standard categories. Expanded payroll integrations make pay-as-you-go smoother and reduce audit swings. For higher-complexity accounts, Next offers policy customization, flexible billing, and add-ons such as business liability and tools coverage. The ability to bundle and keep everything in one login is a big win for solo operators who juggle many client requirements.

I’ve used Next for a lean setup because of the quick quotes and easy COIs. It’s not flashy; it’s fast and clear, which is what I need when a client asks for paperwork by end of day. Support has been responsive in my experience. The help center is written in plain English, and the mobile app makes it painless to grab a certificate from a job site.

How Next Insurance works and key features

Next uses a simple online interface. You answer questions about your work, payroll, and risk class. The quote engine displays options and lets you adjust details before binding. Templates aren’t part of insurance, but you can customize COIs and endorsements to match client needs. Advanced users can connect payroll for pay-as-you-go billing, so premiums track actual wages. Integrations help reduce large audit adjustments. You can monitor claims status and policy documents from the dashboard.

Automation shines in certificates: create, save, and resend COIs quickly. Reporting includes policy details, premium summaries, and basic claims info. For broader needs, you can add general liability, professional liability, and other coverages in one place.

Who Next Insurance is for

Best for solo contractors, handypeople, photographers, consultants, fitness trainers, and small trades who need quick COIs. It’s great for project-based work with changing client requirements. If you have complex multi-state payroll or heavy industrial risk, a traditional carrier or broker might suit you better. No advanced technical skill is required.

Next Insurance pricing

Next prices workers’ comp by state rules, class code, payroll, and claims history. It’s a quote-based model with options for monthly billing and pay-as-you-go through payroll connections. There’s no fixed “plan” tiering like software—coverage is tailored to your business.

  • Workers’ Comp Policy: Quote-based; statutory benefits; coverage per state law; includes COIs.
  • Pay-As-You-Go Billing: Available with supported payroll; helps align premium to real wages.
  • Bundle Options: Add GL, Pro Liability, Tools/Equipment for multi-policy savings.

Compared to peers, Next tends to be competitive for low payrolls and solo operators, especially with bundles. Annual vs. monthly depends on underwriting and your billing preference; pay-as-you-go often smooths cash flow for new or seasonal businesses.

See also  What Burnout Looks Like Before You Recognize It

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Fast online quotes and same-day bind
  • Instant COIs and easy endorsements
  • Pay-as-you-go options reduce audit shocks
  • Strong bundling for one-stop coverage

Cons

  • May not cover every niche class code
  • Complex, multi-state payroll may need a broker
  • Rates vary by state; shopping still matters

If you want speed, clear docs, and flexible billing, Next is a top choice. If you handle heavy-risk operations, look at carriers built for that niche.

Next Insurance reviews

Independent software-style review sites aren’t a perfect fit for carriers. Public ratings are available on platforms like Trustpilot and the BBB, but they change often. I recommend checking current profiles to see the latest feedback.

2. biBERK (Berkshire Hathaway)

Screenshot of biBERK homepage

biBERK is part of Berkshire Hathaway’s insurance group, which gives solo owners access to a carrier with deep financial strength. It’s built for small businesses that want direct, online quotes backed by a household-name insurance provider. Getting started is straightforward: answer a few questions about your trade, payroll, and state. The portal lets you quote, bind, and download certificates. Daily use focuses on COIs, billing, and audits, without long phone waits.

In recent years, biBERK has expanded its digital flow and broadened classes it can price online. That’s handy if you do mixed work like light carpentry plus handyman tasks. Beyond basic coverage, biBERK offers add-ons and bundled policies, such as general liability and BOPs. The Berkshire connection appeals to clients who like seeing strong financial backing on a certificate.

I’ve recommended biBERK to owners who want a big-name carrier without broker friction. The pricing is often sharp for clean, low-claims businesses with predictable payroll. Customer support and documentation are solid. I also like the clarity in their policy docs, less jargon, more straight talk.

How biBERK works and key features

biBERK’s interface is direct and minimal. You plug in details, see a quote, tweak payroll estimates, and bind coverage. You can create COIs and add holders as needed. While there aren’t “templates,” the process is repeatable and quick. Advanced users can integrate payroll for pay-as-you-go in supported setups. You can track premium, endorsements, and claim status from the portal. Reporting focuses on policy docs and audit summaries rather than deep analytics.

Automation helps with reminders and certificate management. biBERK also sells GL, Pro Liability, and BOPs so you can centralize coverage. Support is available by phone and online. “I got my COI the same day and didn’t have to call three times,” is the kind of feedback I hear from time-stressed owners.

Who biBERK is for

Ideal for consultants, trades with steady payroll, home services, fitness, and small retail. It’s a fit if you want direct-from-carrier pricing and recognizable backing. If you have unusual risks or multi-state exposures, a broker marketplace may be better suited to finding a niche carrier. Technical skill isn’t required.

biBERK pricing

biBERK uses state-filed rates, your class code, payroll, and experience to set premiums. Quotes are personalized, and billing can be monthly or tied to payroll where available. Like others here, there aren’t tiered “plans”—just policy options and add-ons.

  • Workers’ Comp Policy: Quote-based; statutory coverage; certificates included.
  • Pay-As-You-Go: Available in supported payroll setups to align premium to actual wages.
  • Bundled Coverages: Add GL, BOP, and more for multi-policy efficiency.

Value is often strong for low-claims, straightforward operations. Annual vs. monthly is flexible; many owners choose pay-as-you-go to avoid audit swings. Always compare a couple of quotes because state class rates can vary by carrier appetite.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Backed by Berkshire Hathaway insurance group
  • Clean online quoting and binding
  • Competitive for simple, low-risk classes
  • Bundling options reduce friction

Cons

  • Not all classes or states priced online
  • Portal reporting is basic
  • Complex risks may need a broker

Choose biBERK for simple, direct coverage from a financially strong carrier. If your risk profile is unusual, consider a marketplace.

biBERK reviews

Public ratings appear on sites like Trustpilot and BBB, but counts and scores change. For the most accurate read, check current profiles and recent comments about claims handling and billing.

3. Pie Insurance

Screenshot of Pie Insurance homepage

Pie Insurance focuses on small businesses and uses technology to price workers’ comp efficiently. They’re known for competitive quotes for price-sensitive trades and have grown distribution through both direct and partner channels. The quote flow is quick: enter business details, payroll, and class codes for an estimate. You can often bind online and issue certificates without waiting days. It’s built for owners who want a straight, budget-friendly path to compliance.

Pie has expanded its availability and underwriting over the last few years, which has helped more niche trades get online quotes. That progress makes it a stronger contender if you struggled to get priced elsewhere. Beyond basics, Pie supports flexible billing and partner payroll connections in many cases. You can pair it with other business coverages through partners to use a single checkout flow.

I’ve seen Pie come in sharp on pricing for light-to-moderate risk contractors and mobile service pros. If your class code is in their sweet spot, the savings can be real. Their support team has been practical and responsive in my calls—clear on documents and timelines, which matters when a client deadline is looming.

How Pie Insurance works and key features

Pie’s interface is simple and efficient. You answer questions, see pricing, and bind if it works for you. COIs are easy to generate, and you can adjust payroll estimates during the year. For more advanced setups, you can connect payroll (where supported) so that billing tracks actual wages. You’ll get access to policy docs, endorsements, and claims contacts from your account.

Automation centers on renewals, billing reminders, and COIs. Reporting covers essentials like premium summaries and audit notices. Extra tools come through partner coverage options so you can round out your insurance stack. Support is available by phone and email. “Quote to COI in a day” is the common experience I hear from busy owners. It’s beginner-friendly and flexible enough to handle small growth spurts.

Who Pie Insurance is for

Great for contractors, handypeople, mobile auto detailers, cleaners, and other field services that want sharp pricing. Works well if you need quick COIs for job bids. If you’re in a high-hazard class or multi-state heavy construction, you may need a specialty broker. No technical skill needed.

Pie Insurance pricing

Pie prices policies by state, class code, payroll, and loss history. It’s fully quote-based. Many policies offer monthly billing and pay-as-you-go via payroll partners to keep cash flow smooth.

  • Workers’ Comp Policy: Quote-based; statutory benefits, certificates included.
  • Flexible Billing: Monthly and pay-as-you-go in supported setups.
  • Coverage Rounding: Add other policies through partners for a streamlined checkout.

Compared to others here, Pie often targets affordability for small operators in eligible classes. Annual savings may apply when bundling. As always, compare at least two quotes for the same payroll and class codes.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Competitive pricing for many small trades
  • Fast quoting and easy COIs
  • Monthly and pay-as-you-go options
  • Growing class and state availability

Cons

  • Not every class code or state is eligible
  • Fewer bells and whistles in the portal
  • Complex risks may need traditional markets

If pricing consistency is your priority and your class fits, Pie is a strong contender. If you’re niche or complex, cast a wider net.

Pie Insurance reviews

As with most carriers here, ratings appear on consumer sites and can fluctuate with volume. I suggest checking current Trustpilot/BBB pages and recent feedback about claims and audits.

4. Thimble

Screenshot of Thimble homepage

Thimble started with flexible liability policies for freelancers and micro-businesses, and now also provides workers’ comp in many states. The draw is fast quotes, easy certificates, and coverage that meets client requirements without long calls. You can start a quote in minutes and see options tuned to your trade. The portal emphasizes COIs and policy docs so you can get hired and start work. It’s very friendly for people who hate paperwork.

See also  Two Week Notice: Writing Guide

Over time, Thimble has broadened its carrier relationships and product range, adding more classes and states. That expansion gives freelancers and small teams a realistic workers’ comp path alongside their on-demand liability. Advanced features include flexible billing and easy certificate management for multiple clients. If you already use Thimble for GL or professional liability, adding comp centralizes things nicely.

I like Thimble for side-gig owners who pitch often and need instant COIs. It keeps admin light so you can focus on getting paid. Support is responsive, and the knowledge base speaks plain English. That matters when a general contractor asks for a specific endorsement on short notice.

How Thimble works and key features

Thimble’s interface is clean and mobile-friendly. You enter business details, choose coverage, and, in many cases, bind online. COIs are quick to create and share, and you can add holders for different clients. For more control, you can manage endorsements and update payroll estimates during the year. While deep analytics aren’t the point, you’ll find clear billing summaries and policy records. Automation includes renewal reminders and certificate storage. Thimble also offers GL, professional liability, and tools coverage, which helps keep your stack simple.

Support comes through chat and email, with phone options available. I’ve found the team practical and fast. It’s a good balance for beginners who value speed and tidy paperwork.

Who Thimble is for

Best for freelancers, photographers, event pros, cleaners, and handypeople who send lots of bids and need instant COIs. Works well for part-time or seasonal work. If you have complex payroll or high-hazard classes, a larger carrier or broker may be better suited. No special technical skills needed.

Thimble pricing

Thimble’s workers’ comp is quote-based and varies by state, class, and payroll. Many policies offer monthly billing. It fits well for small operators who want fast setup and clear documents.

  • Workers’ Comp Policy: Quote-based; state-compliant benefits; instant COIs.
  • Flexible Billing: Monthly options; some pay-as-you-go via partners.
  • Bundled Coverages: GL and professional liability available to round out coverage.

Compared to others, Thimble shines on convenience and speed. Pricing is competitive for many micro-businesses, but always compare with at least one direct carrier.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Very fast quoting and instant COIs
  • Great for frequent bids and changing clients
  • Simple portal; mobile-friendly
  • Easy to bundle with GL/pro liability

Cons

  • Not all classes/states supported
  • Fewer advanced management features
  • High-hazard risks may be referred elsewhere

If you value speed and tidy paperwork above all, Thimble is an easy win. If you need deep customization, consider a larger carrier.

Thimble reviews

Public reviews are available on consumer sites, and many users praise the ease of obtaining proof of insurance quickly. As ratings shift, I suggest checking current profiles to see the latest feedback.

5. The Hartford

Screenshot of The Hartford homepage

The Hartford is a long-established carrier with strong small business programs and well-known endorsements. It offers workers’ comp nationwide with a deep bench in claims and risk control. You can start online or through an agent. The portal supports certificates, endorsements, and billing. It’s not the fastest on quotes in every case, but the claims experience and resources are strengths.

Over the years, The Hartford has expanded its integrations with payroll providers for pay-as-you-go, helping solo owners and small teams avoid big audit swings. Higher-end features include return-to-work support, risk engineering, and training resources. That’s helpful if a client asks about your safety program.

I recommend The Hartford for owners who want sturdy claims handling and expect to grow. It’s a steady choice if you value brand trust and depth of support. Service consistency is a plus. Documentation is detailed, which makes client compliance easier.

How The Hartford works and key features

The Hartford’s digital tools cover quoting, binding (often via agents), and policy management. COIs, endorsements, and billing are available online. The interface is more traditional than some insurtechs but very capable. Advanced capabilities include payroll-linked billing, risk control resources, and dedicated claims support. You can access training materials to support safety compliance.

Reporting focuses on policy records, claims status, and audit summaries. Automation includes reminders and certificate management. You can bundle BOP, auto, and liability for a fuller program. Support is available by phone and through agents. It’s designed for people who prefer a steady, established partner. Overall, it’s powerful for owners who want depth and plan to scale.

Who The Hartford is for

Best for professional services, growing trades, and small employers who value strong claims and risk resources. Great if clients care about carrier pedigree. If you want the absolute fastest self-serve quote, an insurtech might be the quickest option. No technical skills needed; agent help is available.

The Hartford pricing

Pricing is quote-based and follows state rules, class codes, payroll, and loss history. The Hartford supports monthly billing and pay-as-you-go through many payroll partners. You can bundle for potential savings.

  • Workers’ Comp Policy: Quote-based; state-compliant benefits; strong claims support.
  • Pay-As-You-Go: Available via payroll connections to align premium to wages.
  • Program Bundles: Add BOP, GL, auto, and more for a unified program.

Value skews toward owners who want claims depth and risk control. It may price higher than lean insurtechs for some classes but can pay off in support and stability over time.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Strong claims handling and resources
  • Payroll-linked pay-as-you-go options
  • Deep product suite for bundling
  • Trusted national brand

Cons

  • Not always the fastest online quote
  • May cost more for micro-businesses
  • Interface less sleek than newer platforms

Choose The Hartford if you value depth of support and plan to grow. If you only need a quick COI at the lowest cost, try an insurtech first.

The Hartford reviews

There are many public reviews on consumer sites and industry forums, with mixed experiences, as you’d expect from a large carrier. For the clearest picture, read recent comments on claims handling and billing.

6. Cerity (Employers Insurance)

Screenshot of Cerity homepage

Cerity is the online arm of Employers Insurance, a carrier focused on small business workers’ comp. It’s designed for quick quotes and instant bind in many states, with clear pricing for simple class codes. You answer a short set of questions and can often bind coverage the same day. The portal lets you manage COIs and billing without back-and-forth emails.

Cerity has expanded its availability and tightened its quoting workflow over time, making it easier for sole proprietors to get covered quickly. Higher-level needs like payroll-linked billing and multi-policy bundles may route through Employers or partners. Still, for basic comp, Cerity is refreshingly straightforward.

I like Cerity for single-state, low-claims operations that want instant coverage with minimal steps. It’s a practical option if you’re in a supported class. Support is friendly, and the interface emphasizes speed and clarity over extra features.

How Cerity works and key features

Cerity’s interface is streamlined. Enter your business and payroll, review the quote, and bind online. COIs are easy to issue and share with clients. It’s simple enough to handle from your phone. Advanced options like payroll integrations vary; for deeper needs, you may work through Employers or partner channels. Reporting covers policy basics, claims contacts, and audit info.

Automation helps with renewals and certificates. If you need additional coverages, Cerity can guide you to partner solutions. Support is available by chat and email, with phone options. It’s geared to owners who want a fast, no-mystery process. Overall, it’s beginner-friendly and purpose-built for quick compliance.

See also  Self-Employment Tax Help in Bloomington, MN: Local Tax Offices & Experts

Who Cerity is for

Best for sole proprietors, consultants, and light trades in supported classes who want instant bind. If you have multi-state payroll or complex risks, consider a larger carrier or broker. No special technical skills required.

Cerity pricing

Cerity uses quote-based pricing by state, class, payroll, and loss history. Many policies can start with monthly billing, and it’s easy to adjust estimates during the year.

  • Workers’ Comp Policy: Quote-based; statutory coverage; instant COIs in many cases.
  • Flexible Billing: Monthly options; adjustments through the year.
  • Partner Solutions: Pathways to bundle other coverages if needed.

Cerity is often competitive for simple, low-risk classes. Always compare one or two alternatives to confirm you’re getting a fair rate for your code and state.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Instant bind in many states
  • Very simple online experience
  • Backed by a workers’ comp-focused carrier

Cons

  • May lack deeper integrations
  • Not every class/state available
  • Fewer program bundling options directly

Pick Cerity for quick, clean coverage. If you plan to expand into multi-state operations, consider carriers with broader programs.

Cerity reviews

Public consumer reviews exist but are lighter than larger carriers. Because volumes are smaller, ratings can swing—check recent feedback before binding.

7. Simply Business (Marketplace)

Screenshot of Simply Business homepage

Simply Business is an online marketplace and broker that lets you compare workers’ comp offers from multiple carriers. Instead of calling around, you submit one form and see options tailored to your trade and state. The appeal is speed and comparison. You can view quotes, see which carrier will issue COIs fastest, and decide based on billing flexibility. It’s a time-saver if you’re not sure which carrier fits your class code.

In recent years, Simply Business has expanded its carrier panels and improved its digital flow, making it easier to get firm, bindable quotes online. Advanced help comes from licensed agents who can place unusual class codes or guide you through endorsements. That’s valuable if clients ask for specific wording.

I often suggest marketplaces for owners who were declined by one insurtech or got a high quote. Casting a wider net can surface a better fit. Service is solid, and it’s helpful to have a single point of contact, even if the final policy is with a different carrier.

How Simply Business works and key features

You enter your business details once and receive quotes from partner carriers. The interface lets you compare pricing, billing options, and coverage terms. You can often bind online and get COIs quickly. For advanced needs, agents can place specialty classes and handle endorsements. Reporting is basic but clear—policy docs, billing, and certificate management.

Automation includes reminders and document storage. If you want to add GL, BOP, or professional liability, you can do it in the same flow. Support is available by phone and online. “One form, several quotes” is the main win for busy owners. Overall, it’s beginner-friendly and great for comparison shoppers.

Who Simply Business is for

Best for freelancers, trades, and consultants who want to compare carriers without making ten calls. Useful if a prior quote was too high or you were declined. If you already love a specific carrier’s portal, you might go direct. No technical skill required.

Simply Business pricing

As a marketplace, Simply Business doesn’t set prices. It shows carrier quotes based on your state, class, payroll, and loss history. Billing options depend on the selected carrier.

  • Workers’ Comp via Multiple Carriers: Quote-based; state-compliant benefits.
  • Billing Options: Monthly and pay-as-you-go when carriers support them.
  • Bundling: Add GL, BOP, and other coverages from partner carriers.

Value comes from comparison. You can quickly see whether one carrier offers better pricing for your class code than another. Always review terms and endorsements before binding.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • Multiple quotes with one form
  • Agent help for tricky class codes
  • Fast COIs once placed

Cons

  • Experience varies by carrier you choose
  • Portal tools depend on the final carrier
  • May add a step versus going direct if you already know your carrier

If you want to shop around fast, start here. If you prefer a single known portal and brand, go direct to that carrier.

Simply Business reviews

Marketplace reviews are widely available on consumer sites and tend to focus on speed and helpful agents. Because panels evolve, check current ratings and recent comments.

What is the best workers’ comp insurance right now?

My top picks this year are Next Insurance, biBERK, and Pie Insurance. All three make it easy for self-employed pros to get covered quickly, issue COIs on demand, and keep premiums tied to real payroll. Next is my number one. I use it myself. This isn’t sponsored—just my honest take after trying multiple routes. I found Next while hunting for a policy I could bind the same day without a marathon of calls. The clear dashboard, instant COIs, and smooth pay-as-you-go sealed it for me. When a client asks for a new certificate holder at 4:30 p.m., I can send it before 4:40 p.m.

On value, Next has been fair at low payroll, and the bundling discounts helped. Alternatives sometimes quoted higher deposits or less flexible billing. With pay-as-you-go, my monthly outlay tracks actual wages, which matters if revenue swings. For me, that beats a cheaper “headline” rate that later turns into a rough audit bill. biBERK is a close second. If you want the comfort of Berkshire Hathaway’s backing and like dealing directly with a large, financially strong group, it’s an excellent pick. Their quotes for clean, low-claims operations can be very competitive, and the process is refreshingly simple.

What I like most about biBERK is the steady feel—clear documents, straightforward certificates, and the option to bundle with other policies. If I ran a more traditional shop or prioritized a big-name carrier on my COIs, I could have picked biBERK. Pie Insurance is my third choice, especially for budget-conscious trades. If your class code aligns with their appetite, pricing can be strong, and the quote-to-bind flow is quick. For new contractors bidding jobs, that speed can win work.

I also mix tools. For non-comp coverages, I’ve used different providers when a client requested a specific endorsement or when a marketplace surfaced a better niche match. It’s normal to adjust your stack as you grow. Choosing between these top options is tough because your state and class code matter a lot. I stuck with Next because it balanced price, instant COIs, and billing flexibility for my current mix of projects. I hope this helped you feel confident about your next step. Stay safe, stay compliant, and keep the work moving.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Do I need workers’ comp if I’m self-employed with no employees?

Maybe. Some states allow you to exclude yourself, while others require coverage for certain trades or projects. Many clients also require a COI. I always check state rules and the contract before starting work.

Q: What’s the cheapest way to pay for workers’ comp as a solo owner?

Pay-as-you-go billing tied to payroll usually keeps cash flow smooth and reduces audit surprises. I compare at least two quotes and ask about deposits, fees, and certificate costs to avoid extras.

Q: Can I get a workers’ comp “ghost policy”?

Some states allow policies that exclude the owner but provide a COI to satisfy client requirements. Availability and rules vary. I confirm with the carrier and make sure the client accepts it before binding.

Q: How are premiums calculated for self-employed workers’ comp?

Premiums are based on your class code, state rates, estimated payroll, and any prior claims. Endorsements and credits can adjust the final number. I keep payroll estimates realistic and update mid-year to avoid audit shocks.

Photo by sol: Unsplash

About Self Employed's Editorial Process

The Self Employed editorial policy is led by editor-in-chief, Renee Johnson. We take great pride in the quality of our content. Our writers create original, accurate, engaging content that is free of ethical concerns or conflicts. Our rigorous editorial process includes editing for accuracy, recency, and clarity.

Hi, I am Mark. I am the in-house legal counsel for Self Employed. I oversee and review content related to self employment law and taxes. I do consulting for self employed entrepreneurs, looking to minimize tax expenses.